Skip to content
DWT logo
People Services Insights
About Offices Careers
Search
People
Services
Insights
About
Offices
Careers
Search
Insights

Arbitration Clause Can Apply to Nonsignatories

05.06.09
Share
Print this page
The Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled an arbitration clause can be applied against (or for the benefit of) persons who do not sign the clause, as long as governing state law makes that extension to nonsignatories possible. At issue in Arthur Anderson LLP v Carlisle was a tax shelter scheme gone bust, which in turn generated suits by individual investors who had put money into the tax shelters against the advisors and lawyers who recommended the illegal schemes.  Certain LLCs created for the purpose of facilitating the tax scheme (but not the individual investors themselves) signed contracts containing arbitration clauses with one or more of the defendant advisors.When the investors filed suit in federal district court, the defendants moved for a stay under Section 3 of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) on the ground that the issues in the suit were "referable to arbitration under an agreement in writing" under Section 3.  The plaintiff/investors fought this, contending that they are not individually bound by whatever clauses the LLCs had signed.The Supreme Court held that state law governs the issue of whether such clauses can be extended to nonsignatories, and there's nothing in the FAA itself that preempts or overrides whatever the outcome is under that state law.Note:  Washington state law is well-settled on the fact that nonsignatories can in certain circumstances be bound by -- or take advantage of -- arbitration clauses.  See McClure v. Davis Wright Tremaine, 77 Wn. App. 312 (1995). 

Related Articles

2025
Feature
Financial Services
New Administration Outlook: Helping You Navigate Post-Election Uncertainty in 2025 and Beyond Read More External Link
06.20.25
Insights
Food + Beverage
Food Venture Financing News - Weekly Issue No. 241 Read More
06.18.25
Insights
Foundations & Nonprofits
UPDATE: Senate Finance Committee's Version of "The One, Big, Beautiful Bill" Provides Some Relief to Nonprofits Read More
DWT logo
©1996-2025 Davis Wright Tremaine LLP. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Attorney Advertising. Not intended as legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Media Kit Affiliations Legal notices
Privacy policy Employees DWT Collaborate EEO
SUBSCRIBE
©1996-2025 Davis Wright Tremaine LLP. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Attorney Advertising. Not intended as legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.