"Consumer Protection in Crypto," Banking [on] Blockchain Podcast, Episode 5
DWT partner Steve Gannon is joined by partners Eric Goldberg and Melissa Baal Guidorizzi, both former CFPB attorneys, to discuss consumer protection in digital assets and blockchain. They examine the federal and state regulators that may act in this space, the risks consumers face, the impact of the stalled CLARITY Act, and the role industry self-regulation can play in building trust.
Topics Covered
- The patchwork of federal and state regulators, including the CFPB, FTC, state attorneys general, and state banking agencies, that may oversee crypto products.
- Consumer risks such as fast-moving scams, opaque pricing, and limited transaction-point protections, and how industry self-regulation and private network rules can help address them.
- The CFPB's uncertain authority over crypto under the Electronic Fund Transfer Act and UDAAP, and what the CLARITY Act's failure may mean for regulation and enforcement.
Banking [on] Blockchain is a podcast exploring how blockchain and digital assets are reshaping financial services. Subscribe on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
Episode Transcript
Steve: Welcome everyone and welcome back to the next edition of Banking [on] Blockchain. I'm Steve Gannon, a partner at Davis Wright Tremaine, and I'm here with two of my partners, Eric Goldberg and Melissa Baal Guidorizzi, and we're going to talk today about consumer protection and digital assets in blockchain. This series is a Davis Wright Tremaine podcast exploring how blockchain, digital assets, and modern payment technologies are reshaping financial services, and in each episode, DWT attorneys and industry guests unpack the legal, regulatory, and business developments driving this fast moving space. From bank adoption and stablecoins to enforcement actions, infrastructure, and global trends, this is designed for financial institutions, fintech companies, investors, and in-house counsel. The series delivers practical perspectives on what's changing and what's ahead.
So in this episode, as I mentioned, we're going to be discussing consumers, consumer protection, and digital assets and blockchain. And I'm delighted to have Eric and Melissa with us today. They both are veterans of the CFPB, and so they've spent a huge amount of their career in the space of consumer protection. So let me start out with a sort of a big overall umbrella question, which is, what are the consumer protection agencies at the federal and state level that impact or will interact with crypto? And how do they act either independently or collectively?
Melissa: I can start with that. So, you know, for those in the space, it may seem like there's a lot of white space and there's a green field, particularly with the CFPB in its current state. The truth is it's really more of a quilt. There's so many regulators that could take action with regard to crypto products. The CFPB still exists. There is the FTC at the federal level. And then every state has an unfair deceptive acts or practices statute. There are also state banking agencies. So state AGs, state banking agencies, state securities, regulators ... the ability to actually function in this space takes a lot more thought and precision in the wake of federal, perhaps lack of federal, oversight or guidance in this space. And so in some ways I think it's become more difficult rather than easier.
Eric: Yeah, I would just add, you know, the interesting thing about, you know, because Melissa and I both are from the CFPB, and the interesting fact is the CFPB has really not ever regulated cryptocurrencies or crypto products. They've been around a long time. I remember in the early days of the CFPB, we were getting questions about the CFPB's jurisdiction over crypto. And I imagine the CFPB is still getting those same questions because it hasn't answered them yet. And so one of the things that's going to be overarching our discussion today is, particularly with respect to the CFPB, what is its authority and you know, could it regulate crypto?
But then I think as Melissa indicated, the FTC has been around even longer. They regulate fraud and scams for a very long time and whether you're defrauding somebody with crypto or cash or anything else, it's still very much going to be subject to the same laws and that's very similar at the state level as well, where state regulators are using tools they've had for a long time to protect consumers.
Steve: Yeah, you know, Eric, I think that's actually a theme that I've heard in other parts of discussions about crypto as well, which is the form is different, but the underlying substance really hasn't changed all that much. So let's talk first, again kind of level-set. What are some of the consumer dangers, or dangers and risks to consumers, that cryptocurrency presents? I know there are a lot of them. Maybe you guys can sort of chat about a few of them that you have seen or know about and then with that as sort of a table setting we can go into what more can be done to make sure consumers are protected.
Melissa: So I can start. I actually just did a panel with the New York City Bar Association on innovative payment technology and the rise of fraud. And so, to your point, you, Steve and Eric, the issue is when new technologies are put out into this space, particularly now that payments and stablecoin use is much more prevalent, the faster payments, the seamless payments allow for fraud to happen at a faster clip, bigger amounts of money. So all the scams that we saw in fiat, all the account takeover, pig butchering, romance scam issues are becoming even more acute for consumers in the payment space.
Steve: One of the things and maybe Eric you can comment on this, that I've certainly heard about is the opaque pricing that kind of accompanies crypto. It's partially because of what you just said, Melissa, it can be difficult to figure out, what am I really paying for this transaction? It gets executed like that. So, what's really the spread? How do I know that? Eric, any thoughts on that?
Eric: Yeah, not only that, but it's also is it a cryptocurrency I've heard of? I think most people are familiar with Bitcoin. The Bitcoin price is pretty you know, well accessible, as are several of the other major cryptocurrencies. But a lot of the scams are often occurring with what I would call a fly-by-night cryptocurrency where there might be some sort of rug pull event where they get people to invest and then the market tanks. But the other challenge is, yeah, we're used to things in dollars and cents and I think a lot of times when consumers see things priced in crypto denominations, whether it's Bitcoin or something else, it can add to the confusion. And as Melissa said, the speed at which some of these scams happen makes consumers very vulnerable. One of the things we talked about a lot when I was at the Bureau is the more friction there is in a transaction, the more time a consumer has to think about whether that's a transaction they want to enter into. And scammers, they rely on speed and sort of making people act in moments of vulnerability. And that's where we've seen both with crypto and other assets where unfortunately it's the scammers that have had a lot of success.
Steve: The other thing, by the way, there was a recent study done by the consumer products organization that indicated a lack of, and this surprised me, a lack of what's called transaction point protections for consumers. That is, before the transaction actually can be executed, you, the consumer have to, I don't know whether it's check a box, but basically have to acknowledge that you know that you understand that there are fraudsters out there and that you know you've got to protect yourself. So that's something that hopefully we'll see a little bit more of.
Eric: I would just add to that. See, we have seen some of the bigger crypto players very much put that in place. I just moved some of my crypto assets from one platform to another, and the amount of steps I had to go through to move them was like it actually took me a few days to get it all figured out. And that's mostly voluntary, right? These companies that are legitimate, they don't want to be known as platforms that support frauds and scams, just the same way the big banks don't want to be used for frauds and scams. So, you know, one of the things we'll talk about is, you know, where is the motivation to self-regulate. And some of it is, the more legitimate you want to be, the more you need to take steps on your own, particularly when we have a federal government that's relatively hands-off right now.
Steve: Sure, sure. So by the way, speaking of the federal government and hands-off, although kind of maybe involuntarily, we saw a couple of weeks ago that the CLARITY Act failed to get beyond the cloture vote in the Senate. So while it's in limbo now, no one really expects that it's going to be coming back anytime soon, certainly not at least, maybe a version of it will be introduced in 2027... kind of depends, I guess. But in your view, does the failure of the CLARITY Act make consumers more exposed or, do the regulators have the ability, as they seem to be trying to, but the effective ability to sort of fill the gaps, come in, pass regulations and sort of build a rule book that the industry will have to follow in a way that is going to be credible. Melissa, let's start with you.
Melissa: So I think one of the things that keeps the regulatory scheme that we have in this country from doing anything meaningful in that regard is that there's a lot of competition. We have, you know, we have countries that have been more perhaps successful in regulating and setting rules of the road for crypto that are much leaner in its regulatory schema, right? So trying to figure out, just as Congress couldn't agree on the CLARITY Act, you need a lot of different agencies to agree on which parts they're going to take. I think we're at a point where we're closest to be able to do that. Whether or not they'll be able to meet some meaningful accord and then be able to get some regulations out that really provide some guidance, I think will be tough. And with the competing interests that kept the CLARITY Act from actually moving forward, I think there's a reticence at the federal level to put one thumb on the scale here or another place when Congress couldn't do it. So I'm not particularly hopeful that there'll be regulation there.
Steve: Eric, your thoughts?
Eric: Yeah, you know, one, not to make this an administrative law podcast, but the Supreme Court has sort of weakened the ability of federal regulators to make permanent regulations. Plus you add to the political nature of all of this, then it swung wildly from one administration to the next. It makes it certainly less certain for businesses trying to get clear instruction on what the rules of the road are. And in practice that creates more gaps for consumers who are trying to get products that work in a sensible way. On the other hand, you know, of all the frauds and scam stuff we just talked about, all that stuff was already illegal and has been illegal for a long time. And so, back to your original question, there are a lot of tools the regulators have already without new laws needing to be passed to protect consumers. Now when you get into whether and how these products should be regulated, that's where, you know, you get into questions of whether the SEC, CFTC, whomever has the actual authority, whether they are staying within what Congress told them to do. Or whether they're pushing the envelope, which makes it much more likely to get struck down by a court or by a subsequent administration.
Steve: You know, there already is at least one challenge to, and this is not a strictly a consumer protection, but as you guys know, the OCC has granted conditional approval for a number of National Trust Bank charters this year. And just last Friday, the ICBA filed a lawsuit in the District of Columbia challenging the grant of those charters as beyond the statutory authority of the OCC to act. So it will be an interesting pulling of the string to figure out, you know, did the OCC use its statutory powers in a fulsome way that's fine or did it go beyond its perimeter, and with, you're a 100% right, not failure but with the overturning of Chevron, the discretion of course that regulators used to have isn't there anymore. So it'll be an interesting back and forth. But in terms of consumer protections, what role does the industry have? We mentioned this earlier and Eric, I'm going to go to you first on this one. What role do you think the industry has in attempting, whether or not regulations wind up being passed, wind up being challenged, what role does the industry have to better regulate itself in a way that will enhance its credibility?
Eric: Certainly, from any nascent payment technology, and I'll put crypto in that bucket, consumers have certain expectations they bring to it that their transactions are going be protected, that, you know, they'll get their money back if their account is drained by a criminal and all of that. And if you look back historically, a lot of that has been done by private networks. So you've obviously got the card networks where we're all paying interchange fees, and part of those fees go to cover and protect ourselves from frauds and unauthorized transactions. We've seen similar with the ACH networks, and even to some extent with wire transfers. And a lot of the industry who developed those products want to make sure that there is a baseline of protections. And consumers, as they enter these new payment methods, there's a certain expectation, I think, that they have. And so one reason we've not seen consumer adoption of some crypto products, I think, is in part because consumers just think they're too risky. And so until either there's statutory changes, which seem very unlikely as you noted, or more likely some sort of private network or private effect of protect consumers, whether it's via contract, network rules or what have you, that's what I think would lead to more long term adoption. And we're starting to see that, for example, you know, in the agentic payment space, where there's been some discussion about how to protect consumers who are using alternative rails to make payments, and make sure they're protective the way they are when they use their credit cards or ACH transfers.
Steve: So Melissa, what do you think the industry should be doing like in terms of their public face to enhance their credibility? So now that there may be a little bit of a thought that, well, gee, without CLARITY we're back to the Wild West. What can the industry do to enhance its ability to make a credible case that consumers are going to be protected?
Melissa: Well, we have the opportunity to see a lot of different types of players in our practice. And so what you have is some folks that are going to go along the lines that you're talking about, Steve, really trying to expand the use of crypto and stablecoin into consumer products. They want to be trusted, they want to have real alternatives to maybe more traditional financial institutions or work hand in hand to create seamless products for consumers and improve them. And you'll see those maybe do the things that Eric talked about, really try to lean into creating networks or disclosures or some sort of rules of the road for themselves so people can use those products and have some clarity around what they're doing, pun intended.
But then you also do have a lot of Wild West folks, these start-up folks who really feel like now that this is open, it is now back to years ago when there was no one on the street willing to look and take care of consumers in this space. And I just don't think that's going to be a correct bet going forward, because we are all much smarter about how this works even if it hasn't been adopted broadly in the consumer space. So I would say one of the things when I was at the CFPB, I was ... we were in slightly different offices. I was in the Office of Enforcement, but I got to see exams and investigation work. And you know, to the extent there are existing laws, consumer protection laws that could apply, "they are your guide, industry." And so if your product it seems like another product that is regulated, the closer you can get to that type of functionality, regulation and use case, you know, protecting someone, any disputes related to account transfers, things like that, then you become a more trusted partner and your product is more sustainable and scalable regardless of what happens with the political world. But I do think to your point, Steve, I think there are more Wild West folks out there and it's going to keep the adoption from moving forward at the pace that I think some others might want.
Steve: So you mentioned the CFPB, so let's talk about the CFPB just for a little bit, you guys both being longstanding veterans of that agency. So CFPB obviously has survived. and by the way, its funding has survived. I read that there was another circuit court opinion that came down basically saying, no, the federal funding is the same and it doesn't get diminished because the Fed didn't make money in a given year on its balance sheet.
So the funding is going to stay in place and apparently, at least what I read is it's going to be like the original statutory scheme imagined, pretty much at the discretion of the director. And so funding is going to be there going forward. What more should the CFPB be doing in order to add additional protections for consumers or to just simply shore up the consumer protections that already exist when it comes to the cryptocurrency world? Eric, well let's start with you.
Melissa: So I think Eric yeah, Eric is a good person to start.
Steve: Yeah. You're the senior guy here on the CFPB matters.
Eric: Great. So I mean I think the biggest question for the CFPB, there's two questions for the CFPB really. One is, how are consumers using these products? Are they using them as Melissa was saying in the same way that they use other consumer finance products? So, no one disputes the CFPB's ability to regulate money transmission. And if consumers who were sent, say consumers go from sending money home to family members abroad via, you know, traditional remittance services and move that to a crypto product, CFPB should understand how consumers are using those and whether those providers are providing the same protections. But then you very quickly get to the question, assuming that's the answer to those questions are yes, what is the CFPB's authority? And as I indicated earlier, CFPB has declined since crypto was created 15 years ago to opine on whether it can regulate cryptocurrencies, particularly under the Electronic Fund Transfer Act and Regulation E. Congress passed that law in 1978 to regulate electronic transfers of funds, electronic fund transfers, but they didn't define what funds are. I think because in 1978 there wasn't a lot of confusion about what funds were. On the other hand, it's meant to protect consumers using various electronic payment systems. So there's sort of arguments on both sides of that.
But as we talked about, the CFPB is not the final say anymore as to what an ambiguous term in the statute means. So even if the CFPB went ahead and tried to regulate crypto products under EFTA and regulation E, it would almost certainly get challenged at court. So then you get into, I think where Melissa would probably go first, is just general UDAP authority and maybe Melissa you want to chime in.
Melissa: Well, I mean, going back to Reg E and you know, Eric and I have some really interesting coverage over this because Eric helped you know, he managed writing updates to the rule and then I would help figure out how to enforce them and interpret them in exams and litigation enforcement actions. So I think there have been, you know, if you don't have the CFPB with the authority, then it goes to the courts and, unfortunately, what that ends up with is inconsistent opinions even in the same district. So the Southern District of New York, for instance, had sort of differing views on whether or not Electronic Fund Transfer Act covers crypto.
But even if you take Reg E off the table, the unfair deceptive abusive acts and practices authority under the Consumer Financial Protection Act not only sits with the CFPB, but arguably each state AG has access to the abusive prong, even if their state doesn't have it. And so again, really if your functionality is transmitting funds or transmitting crypto just like you would transmit fiat, then it may be unfair, deceptive, or abusive if you do it and try not to have any protections around it. And some of the early, I mean you saw some of the P2P early actions from the CFPB use UDAP authority for new technologies that were not put out in this bureau's thought process correctly, the unfairly... and so I think that authority will stand and unfortunately what you may have is a whack-a-mole of certain states because you have 50 states that could be on the case.
Eric: One thing I would just add about the CFPB's authority that I think is clearer is that if you are using crypto behind the scenes, so if you offer a money transfer service that a consumer pays dollars in, the recipient receives dollars on the other end, and there's a stablecoin or whatever is used in the middle, basically behind the scenes to transmit those funds, I think you have a much tougher argument that Regulation E doesn't apply to that transaction.
Steve: The other thing that strikes me, I'm wondering if you guys agree with this, is that nobody questions the CFPB's ability to examine banks. And over time I think we have this image in our head that well banks are against crypto. Actually it's the reverse of that. That's why we wrote Banking [on] Blockchain. There's a growing adoption within bank infrastructures of crypto, certainly for payments, and you've got massive outside organizations like SWIFT, like DTCC, like the New York Stock Exchange, NASDAQ, all developing tokenized products and rails. And you have predictions that all securities in the near-term are going be tokenized. So when you have your wealth management business using tokenization, and you have infrastructure rails that are tokenized, and then you have maybe your corporate treasury also using tokenized assets to help manage the bank's liquidity, over time, crypto is just going to become part of banking and it's going to be yet another product that will be sold. I mean my own prediction, you guys can agree or disagree, is that over time the CFPB will be back into banks examining crypto just like another product.
Eric: Yeah, you know, that very well be happening already, right? Because if the banks are using that crypto to provide things that the CFPB clearly has authority over, whether it's deposit accounts, money movement, lending, then there's no reason the CFPB can examine you know, the bank subject to its authority and larger participants for those activities.
Steve: Sure. Sure
Melissa: But what important argument from a consumer protection standpoint, if you do find yourself in an examination posture, is that the use of those technologies in the ways that you just noted them, Steve, can really solve some of the problems that plague consumers. If you do not have a lag time in settlement, then NSF and overdraft go away. So in fact, there is some really good consumer protective use cases for the blockchain and crypto assets. And it's one of the reasons why I was more interested in working with folks on how to make sure we could use it correctly versus, you know, just sort of a red X on being able to use it at all.
Steve: Yeah, there you couldn't be, you could not be more right, Melissa. I think there are because the current system, fiat rails, are based on intermediation, there are lots of fees that get taken at different stops along the way. And with blockchain technology, most if not all of those fees go away, which is obviously a benefit to the consumer and we can think of cross-border payments as a good example of that. But you know that being said, I wonder whether the CFPB would be in the business of, for example, prescribing, because with smart contracts you can put in place lots of protections for consumers. I kind of wonder if the CFPB, not tomorrow or not next month, but down the road, would be in the business of going to banks and saying ... or other you know related financial institutions over which they have statutory authority of non-depository institutions ... and saying, you know, there are protections that can be put in place that are pretty solid, that are technological protections, not policies. We get all the policy stuff, but things that actually mechanically work to prevent consumer harm, and you're not doing it. So explain to us why you're not doing it. Do you guys see that somewhere in the future?
Eric: Yeah, certainly you would like to see the CFPB take a more active role in sort of highlighting and addressing these issues and bringing industry participants together, even if it's not going to get to the point of as you said, Steve, of actually prescribing regulations and rules. But the problem is that we've had just kind of a vacuum in this space, right? So there really hasn't been any because the CFPB has been worrying about its future in the first instance, getting into regulating innovative products has been pretty far afield and the other part is, you know, the CFPB is so worried, I think, about wading into politically sensitive areas that it's going to be even more reticent to do so here. But when I was at the Bureau and since I've left, there's been lots of discussions on a range of issues where the CFPB could do a lot to bring industry participants together to agree on sensible solutions, and we just haven't seen that under either administration.
Melissa: So I have a little bit of a twist on that, even when it was on full throttle, the CFPB was not interested necessarily in being prescriptive all the time. I know that's probably going to be a controversial thought to some of the folks listening to this, but the staff itself was not willing to really be prescriptive. And because technologists don't sit in these federal agencies and there are even fewer staff, the ability for an agency like the CFPB to even test some of those smart contracts or understand them is probably going to be limited, even if things turn around and they start being more active. So, one of the things I think would be helpful for those who really do want to be trusted players in this space is to create its own compliance system that is explainable and take charge of their own destiny. It's sort of a choose your own adventure idea. You sit there and you provide an explanation that you know you can give to someone else, and then you might be the one who gets adopted as the standard. I think there's an opportunity for that, and we've been working with some on different issues with some trades to really say, okay, you might be confused, different eight federal agencies, on how to do something. Let us tell you what would be helpful for those of us who are willing to be very active in partnering with you, and that could be something to think about.
Steve: Sure. The last question and then we'll wrap it up because this is maybe a prediction. Well, I'm going to ask you to predict the future. So CLARITY did not go forward, and so does this mean we're going to be back to regulation by enforcement and all the kind of hodge-podgey ecosystem that tends to create, or is there going to be another path forward?
Melissa: I have a different view about what regulation by enforcement is because I've sat on both sides. I managed litigation for a big international financial institution and then I was at the CFPB in the Office of Enforcement. I do think that is the way it's going to go in the short-term, mostly because there are going to be some AGs at the state level that are really going and we've already seen some of the California DFAL and legislation enforcement happening. I think that's going to happen and it's going to be a challenge for some folks in the industry. But when I was in-house, one of the things you know, when you're not in the caption, if you can take this note, one of the things that those cases can do is because they're based on particular facts, they can help guide you in building a system for your company that can pass muster in a low-regulatory but high-confusion environment, right? And that way you can use it as sort of a ticket to say, this is how someone else interpreted it. Maybe you should do that, and we're not doing that. It's a distinguishing factor. So I think the bad news is yes, there'll be regulation by enforcement. The good news is, if you can stay out of the caption, you can use those cases going forward to help you.
Steve: Eric, what do you think?
Eric: And you are certainly going to continue to see enforcement of, you know, things that are clearly illegal, frauds and scams and you know violation of AML laws, where there's not been as much dispute over the years. Where it gets a lot harder and I think regulators are going to be even more reticent than they were before, is to push novel theories about their jurisdiction and novel theories about the application of older laws to newer products. So we haven't seen the CFPB wade into that. We saw the SEC try to do that and they got slapped down pretty hard both by public pressure and by the courts and everything else. So I'm not sure where this goes and that leads us back to I think where we talked before about the best chance for like clear rules of the road is self-regulation. And if you want consumers to adopt and use your products, make it so that they're protected if something goes wrong. The challenge is crypto has been very much against that. It's been very much a libertarian-focused product where they're sort of buyer beware. And that's not the way our consumer protection system works. So eventually I feel like we will need sensible policymakers, when that happens, I don't know. But that is ultimately the only way to get sort of clear permanent standards the way we've gotten in credit and under TILA and in payments under EFTA over the last 50 years.
Steve: Yeah, I'll add my two cents into that. I think it's going to be sort of "son of regulation by enforcement." So it's going to be some enforcers, probably mostly at the state level, but you're going to have trade groups jumping in, just like the ICBA did. And so that have a different point of view as to how crypto should advance or not advance. And the difficulty will begin to arise if we begin to get injunctive relief from courts that reverses what's happening and also sort of stands in the way of innovation because where we're standing right now, the innovation and changes in products and changes in markets, particularly by the way, Eric ... subject near and dear to your heart, the advent of agentic AI. It's happening so fast, it's faster than policymakers can respond and react. And it's also very difficult for I mean you look at the composition of Congress, I mean, how many members of the Senate do you really think understand agentic AI?
Eric: They just figured out the internet a few years ago, so...
Steve: Yeah, right. Well, yeah, to our point. So I do think we're going to have a very interesting you know, clash of the titans, if you will, those who want to slow it down and pull back, and those who are innovating all around the globe and want to push this forward, it's going to be hard for the regulators to referee that, I think.
Eric: It is. other than, you know, unfortunately what we've seen in other markets is having bad things happen and they having to come in after the fact to clean up the mess. And that might be what gives them the political cover to finally act.
Steve: Yes. Yeah, and I will say this and I'll end on this. I have an optimistic view going forward because to your point, Melissa, I do think people learn their lesson from FTX, from Terra Luna, Celsius, BlockFi, and so forth that to be unregulated can mean irresponsible players come in, they don't give good disclosures, they don't have safety valves on their products, and that really drags down the whole industry. And I think for most, I'll call them senior-industry players, if you will, they don't want to see that happen again. That was a disaster. And so there's going to be a motivation to try to make sure that the house is in order and stays in order. Because there's too much money to be lost. And too much money to be made if you do it correctly. So in closing comments, certainly lots of issues to be worked through, but overall, I'm reasonably optimistic. And with that, I want to thank you guys for coming to this issue of Banking [on] Blockchain. Love the discussion. I know there's even more to talk about down the road, and for those who are listeners, if there's anything DWT can do to help you work through your issues, just please let us know. Thanks very much.
Eric: Thank you, Steve. Thanks, Melissa.
Melissa: Thank you.