"FCA Qui Tam Litigation After Zafirov: What the Eleventh Circuit's Ruling Means for Healthcare and Government Contractors," Health Law Pulse, Davis Wright Tremaine Webinar
The False Claims Act (FCA) remains the federal government's primary tool for combating fraud, generating billions of dollars in recoveries each year. Recent constitutional challenges, however, have raised fundamental questions about whether private whistleblowers, known as relators, can continue to bring FCA claims on behalf of the United States.
In a closely watched decision, the Eleventh Circuit reversed a district court ruling that had declared the FCA's qui tam provisions unconstitutional under the Appointments Clause. While the ruling preserves the current FCA enforcement framework, significant questions remain, including the possibility of Supreme Court review.
Join DWT partner Ross Siler for a discussion of the Eleventh Circuit's decision, the constitutional arguments shaping FCA litigation, and the practical implications for healthcare providers, life sciences companies, government contractors, and other regulated organizations. Viewers will gain insight into emerging litigation trends, enforcement risks, and key developments to watch in the months ahead.
Webinar Transcript
Ross Siler: Well, thanks for joining. I hope you are having a good pre-Thanksgiving week. I'm excited to give this presentation today. It's one that I've wanted to do for a long time. I really was waiting for the Eleventh Circuit to rule in the Zafroff case that we'll talk about for a year plus, before I could give this presentation, and the Eleventh Circuit issued its opinion on September 1st, and I signed up right away for the next available Health Law Pulse webinar, so thanks for joining and finding the topic interesting. My name's Ross Siler, I'm a partner in our healthcare group in the Seattle office, where it is sunny. Surprisingly, today. I handle government investigations and false claims act cases. I also litigate class actions, consumer protection cases, and complex payer disputes. If it touches healthcare and litigation, that's in my wheelhouse.
As I'm sure many know, the False Claims Act is the federal government's primary litigation tool for combating fraud. The government recovers billions of dollars annually from the thousands of False Claims Act cases that are brought. And this Zafrov case, presented the greatest challenge to the FCA's framework in probably a generation. If you Google Zafrov, you will come up with dozens of Client advisories and analyses by major law firms, regarding the case, and it had that significant implications to false claims at cases nationally. If the Eleventh Circuit case had come out differently, I expect you would have seen dismissal motions filed in waves across the country, or at a minimum, motions seeking to stay these cases pending a potential ruling at the U.S. Supreme Court.
So, in this presentation, I'll cover what the Eleventh Circuit ruling means for healthcare and government contractors. We'll start with background of the False Claims Act and the structure permitting key Tam suits by private plaintiffs, called relators. In the most simplified explanation, relators file suit and the government must decide, whether to intervene. And take over the lawsuit, or not intervene, and leave it for the relator to, prosecute. Relators then have the ability to recover a portion of any judgment or settlement they obtain, even when the government does not intervene. And it's these non-intervened lawsuits where the relator can bring a years-long lawsuit in the name of the United States, that have caused the greatest amount of constitutional concern. We'll also cover the record-setting number of FCA suits filed in fiscal year 25. They accounted for some $7 billion in recoveries for the government. The concerns about the constitutionality of key Tam provisions that three U.S. Supreme Court justices expressed in 2023, which really started the ball rolling on this set of cases.
And those concerns, you know, seemingly still exist, and I suspect they will be, addressed by the court in the next 2 to 3 years. We'll discuss the Florida Federal District Court Judge's 2024 ruling that dismissed a key Tam suit as violating the Constitution's Appointments Clause, and that set the stage for the Eleventh Circuit's ruling, in September, which reversed the District Court, but left many future questions unanswered. And, you know, what comes next for False Claims Act cases, as well as the federal government's new WIP program, the Fraud Whistleblower Incentive Program, that'll fast-track payments to whistleblowers whose tips result in criminal charges, though not necessarily prosecutions. This WIP program is a really interesting, companion to the FCA. So, please jump in with any questions, as we go.
As mentioned, the False Claims Act is the government's primary litigative tool for combating fraud and for fraud recovery. It was enacted in 1863 by President Lincoln to address stupendous abuses in the sale of provisions and munitions to the War Department during the Civil War. The government had been billed for non-existent or worthless goods, charged exorbitant prices for goods delivered, and generally robbed in purchasing the necessities of war. The modern FCA took shape with a set of amendments in 1986 that increased financial incentives for whistleblowers to come forward with fraud claims, and that's resulted in sort of this explosion of cases that we see today. This description of the history of the False Claims Act is from recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions.
In the Supreme Court's words, the FCA creates an unusual and unique public-private enforcement scheme. The government can bring in action concerning false or fraudulent claims, but so can private individuals called relators. The specific statutory language is found in 31 U.S.C. 3729, And it provides that any person who knowingly presents or causes to be presented a false or fraudulent claim for payment or approval is liable to the government for troubled damages. and a civil penalty that's currently valued at between $14,308 and $28,619 per violation. There's a sliding scale that increases annually, tied with cost of living and inflation adjustments. So, the government has the ability to recover both trouble damages and a per-violation civil penalty. And the scope of liability can be absolutely enormous. especially in healthcare government contracting cases, where numerous false claims were alleged to be submitted. For example, repeated false billings of the same type of medical procedure, the liability can be astronomical.
The case that I really think exemplifies this in 2015, so over a decade ago now at this point, the Department of Justice obtained a $237 million, judgment that essentially bankrupted a South Carolina healthcare system. That judgment was settled for $72.4 million. So, you know, that was the maximum recovery the government could keep while essentially keeping this system still afloat. The FCA punishes companies that have committed fraud in government contracts and serves an important function in deterring other companies from doing the same. And it's also not just the potential liability under the FCA, it's the duration of these cases. The complaint in Zafirov was filed in May 2019. You know, I've seen FCA cases that have gone up and down to appeals courts and have taken a decade or more. In my own experience, I had a 2-year FCA case, but that was pushed by very aggressive federal prosecutors, who wanted to see resolution quickly. I've had other FCA cases that have taken multiple years. So, you know, the cost of responding to an investigation and litigating even before any liability determination can be really sizable.
So, what constitutes a knowingly false or fraudulent claim for payment, in violation of the FCA? A person must have either actual knowledge. of the false information, act in deliberate ignorance of the truth or falsity of the information, or act in disregard of the truth or falsy of the information. There's no requirement that the person have specific intent to defraud. And the Supreme Court, in a 2023 case called Super Value, held that the person's subjective knowledge about falsity of the information is what matters, which makes dismissal of an FCA suit difficult given this factual question. You may have heard of Super Value in previous year in review false fraud and abuse presentations.
A claim is defined as any request or demand for money or property presented to an officer, employee, or agent of the United States, or a grantee or other recipient of federal funds. So, providers who submit claims to the Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, other federal healthcare programs are potentially liable if they submit false claims in violation of the FCA.
The elements for an FCA claim per the Ninth Circuit, in a case that was decided just this year. The defendant must have made a false statement or engaged in a fraudulent course of conduct. The statement or conduct was carried out with the requisite center, that's the knowledge standard that we just discussed, actual knowledge, deliberate ignorance, disregard. The statement or conduct has to be material to the government's decision to pay the claim. No FCA violation if the government would have paid the claim anyway, regardless of, you know, the statement's materiality. And the statement or conduct caused the government to pay out money or to forfeit money due.
You know, where the constitutional concerns arise is not with the government itself bringing in FCA action, but with these private relators. A private relator bringing an FCA case doesn't have to be injured themselves to establish standing, they just have to have knowledge of potentially fraudulent claims that were submitted to the government for payment. And they're authorized to pursue these claims for a partial assignment of the government's share of the monetary recovery. The FCA's key Tam provision in 31 USC 3730 permits a relator to bring a civil action for a violation of Section 3729 for the person and for the United States government, and the actions shall be brought in the name of the government. So, you see these FCA complaints, and they're captured… they're captioned, United States, XREL, the whistleblower's name versus the healthcare system, or provider, or the government contractor, that allegedly submitted the false claims.
The relator serves a sealed complaint and a written disclosure of substantially all material evidence and information the person possesses on the government, and there's a minimum 60-day seal period while the government investigates the allegations. before the end of the 60-day period, and the period is usually extended to permit investigation into, you know, what are often complex allegations. The government must decide whether to intervene and take over the action. or leave it for the relator to prosecute themselves. And the constitutional concerns are the most pronounced when the government declines to intervene, and you have contrasting portrayals, sort of, of how much latitude relators have in proceeding.
On one side of the coin, relators can prosecute an action for years. You know, we discussed that some of these actions, like Zafrov, are 6-, 7-year cases. With minimal oversight, you know, from busy federal prosecutors. You know, they can serve extensive discovery, the relators can incur significant discovery burdens for the government. They can proceed to trial, and they can decide whether to pursue appeals that are binding on the government. And on the other hand, you know, the Supreme Court has held that the government always retains the right to intervene in an action, even if an action where the government previously declined to intervene, and it can dismiss under what's a very liberal standard, even if the relator objects. So there's always, you know, at least this minimal degree of control by the government, even in cases where it declines to intervene.
The FCA provides significant financial incentives for relators, you know, really regardless of whether the government intervenes. If the government intervenes, the relator can recover between 15% and 25% of the proceeds. of the action or the settlement of the claim. If the government does not intervene, the relator can recover between 25 and 30% of the proceeds of their successful action. The relator can recover their reasonable attorney's fees and costs, plus their expenses, and these were part of the amendments to the False Claims Act in 1986 that led to, you know, this explosion in cases that we see today. So if you add it all up, you know, treble damages. per violation penalties, reasonable attorney's fees, costs, and expenses, the amount that is potentially at stake in these FCA cases is really sizable.
If you're curious, the single largest relator award in history was $250 million, to a relator in a $900 million settlement that Biogen reached in 2022, related to kickbacks to prescribers of a multiple sclerosis drug. The whistleblower was the former director of regional marketing, and the government did not intervene in that case.
So the implications of ZAFROB and a constitutional challenge to the FCA's key Tam provisions are really clear from the number of these cases and the government's recoveries. The most recent data is for fiscal year 2025. This was announced in January 2026, so we should be getting updated data here in the next two months. False Claims Act settlements and judgments exceeded a record $6.8 billion for fiscal year 2025. Relators also filed a record 1,287 key Tam suits. The previous record was 980 lawsuits filed in FY24, so you're seeing a one-third increase in just a year there.
Healthcare fraud was by far the largest source of these FCA judgments and settlements, accounting for $5.7 billion of the $6.8 billion total. I've been practicing for 13 years, and my three largest FCA cases were all healthcare-related. One involved in alleged medically unnecessary spine surgeries, one involved alleged medically unnecessary patient encounters in skilled nursing facilities. And one involved alleged violations of the anti-kickback statute, related to dental procedures with AKS violations, being predicate FCA violations. So that gives you kind of a sense of. what the government is prosecuting and what actions are being brought in FCA cases. The Trump administration has been an enthusiastic supporter of the FCA and has really emphasized fraud enforcement, as evidenced by this quote by now Attorney General Todd Blanch. We will continue to deploy the FCA to protect taxpayer dollars and hold all fraudsters accountable.
Key Tam actions have been on the rise since 1986, when Congress increased the financial incentives for whistleblowers to bring claims. And the constitutionality of these key Tam actions might have been debated, but it wasn't really seriously questioned until 2023, when a case called Polanski reached the Supreme Court. You might have heard of Polanski in previous year in review fraud and abuse presentations. Polanski was really an unremarkable case regarding whether the government can dismiss an FCA suit over a relator's objection if the government doesn't initially intervene, and what the dismissal standard is then for the government. And the court ruled 8-1 that the government can dismiss in such circumstances. I mentioned it earlier, it's a very deferential standard, whereby the government can dismiss even if a relator objects. But what was notable about Polanski, wasn't necessarily the majority opinion, it was that three justices signaled their interest, in the constitutionality of the FCA's key Tam provisions in their concurring and dissenting opinions.
Justice Thomas went the furthest as the lone dissenter. He would have remanded to the Third Circuit to consider whether the Constitution nonetheless requires dismissal of the suit. He wrote, the FCA's QTam provisions have long inhabited something of a constitutional twilight zone. There are substantial arguments that the QTam device is inconsistent with Article 2, and that private relators may not represent the interests of the United States in litigation. He is relying on unitary executive theory, and that executive power in conducting civil litigation on behalf of the United States cannot be done by a private relator who is not appointed by the president. And the unitary executive theory is really central to some of the major recent Trump administration Supreme Court cases that we've seen, such as the cases on presidential immunity, the president's ability to fire agency heads, like Lisa Cook from the Federal Reserve. They all rely on these unitary executive principles.
In his dissent, Justice Thomas noted the primary counter-argument that key Tam suits have been around since the first Congress, and this is an obstacle to originalists, the fact that, key Tam suits have been around since the first Congress, and dating to the 18th century. George Washington, Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, and John Marshall, you know, these are quite literally the founders, opined on key Tam suits, but they never really questioned their constitutionality. But Justice Thomas' conclusion is standing alone. Historical patterns cannot justify contemporary violations of constitutional guarantees, even when the practice in question covers our entire national existence and indeed predates it. He concluded there is good reason to suspect that Article 2 does not permit private relators to represent the United States' interests in FCACs. And you will see this sort of chain of opinion from Justice Thomas kind of circling down to courts of appeals and district court judges who sort of share his approach and judicial mindset.
In addition, Justices Kavanaugh and Barrett, in a short concurrence, agreed with Justice Thomas that there were substantial arguments with the FCA's key Tam provisions are potentially unconstitutional. Justice Kavanaugh wrote, quote, In my view, the court should consider the competing arguments on the Article 2 issue an inappropriate case. So, following Polanski in 2023, there are seemingly 3 out of 4 votes, needed to grant certification jury, and the Supreme Court waiting for an appropriate case to consider, key Tam constitutionality.
And then, a little over a year later, in September 2024, Zafrov appeared to be the case that the Supreme Court might be waiting for. A federal… a Florida federal district court judge, Catherine Kimball Mizell, dismissed a 5-year-old FCA case, concluding that the key Tam relator violated the Appointments Clause. Judge Mizell clerked for Justice Thomas, and not surprisingly, followed much of his reasoning from Polanski.
The Appointments Clause is part of Article 2, and provides that the President shall appoint ambassadors, other public ministers and consuls, judges of the Supreme Court, and all other officers of the United States, which shall be established by law. The Congress may by law vest the appointment of such inferior officers as they think proper, and the President alone. In the courts of law or in the heads of departments. So the question, at least as related to the Appointments Clause, is whether relators are considered officers of the United States and require presidential appointment. And again, this is most relevant for cases where the government does not intervene, or the government does not bring an FCA case itself, and the relator is left to prosecute the action, you know, for themselves and for their own benefit.
Judge Mazzell believed that relators were officers. Under Supreme Court precedent, anyone who exercises significant authority pursuant to the laws of the United States and who occupies a continuing position established by law qualifies as an officer. You know, this is the test the Supreme Court recognized in this Lucia case, for what constitutes an officer requiring presidential or other employment. Someone who exercises significant authority and who occupies a continuing position, established by law.
The background on Zafirov was the relator sued her employer for violating the FCA by submitting false diagnosis codes to Medicare to generate increased patient payments. And I do not know, like, what potential relator share Zafrov is looking at to conceivably, you know, continue litigating this case. For now, going on 7 years at this point. Zaffro's tenure as a relator has stretched so long that she doesn't actually live in the United States anymore. She moved to Canada, and Judge Mazzell noted that, when she issued her ruling dismissing the suit. The government, declined to intervene initially, but later intervened to defend the FCA's constitutionality after the defendants moved for judgment on the pleadings, when they sort of saw an opening following Polanski.
Judge Mazel concluded that Zaporov exercises significant authority, and indeed core executive power under the continuing position of relator, but lacked the proper appointment under the Constitution. She emphasized that under the FCA, Zafrov had the ability to pursue treble damages and other daunting monetary penalties. Zafrov had the… could determine, you know, which defendants to sue, which theories to raise, which motions to file, and which evidence to obtain. and to potentially pursue an appeal and decide which arguments to preserve, which would bind the federal government. Essentially, a relator in a case where the government hasn't been… hasn't intervened. can go all the way to trial and, you know, obtain what is a binding judgment on the United States with potentially minimal oversight, by federal prosecutors.
I don't know that the focus of constitutional arguments are on whether relators possess significant authority to be considered officers. Judge Mazzell concluded that Zafrog exercised core executive power by deciding how to prioritize and how aggressively to pursue legal actions against defendants who violate the law.
Some more highlights from her ruling. By suing on behalf of the United States to secure, essentially, punitive penalties, a relator performs a traditional, exclusive function of the government that is integral to the administration and enforcement of the public law. That kind of core executive power is significant authority, and that a relator ordinarily files a single action in no way undercuts the immense power the FCA grants her, nor does the FCA preclude a relator from initiating subsequent actions. And as a practical point, relators collectively prosecute most FCA actions, so they indeed hold the primary responsibility in the field. Judge Mazzell was responding to arguments that relators don't possess significant authority when they file a single action of unknown duration.
The question of whether relators occupy a continuing position of law is really tougher when you think about a relator often filing just a single action. There are relators who bring multiple actions, but I've never experienced one. They always have been employees of the health system, or colleagues of the provider whose claims were challenged. But Judge Mazel analogized the role of relator to independent counsels and bank receivers, because both of those roles have been held to be officers under the Appointments Clause. And Morrison v. Olson is the most notable case where the Supreme Court concluded that an independent counsel was an inferior officer requiring appointment.
More from Judge Mazzell and how she characterized relators. She wrote that Relators self-appoint as special prosecutors to recover punitive damages against private parties on behalf of the federal government. And like bank receivers, relators are appointed to handle a specific problem at the conclusion of which their term in office ends. Bank receivers are similarly empowered to initiate litigation on behalf of the United States to enforce a complex regulatory scheme with serious implications for the public FISC and for targeted defendants. And not to spoil the ending, but you'll see that the Eleventh Circuit disagreed with Judge Mazel's conclusion that relators occupy a continuing position. And it is interesting to just think about the concept of a relator, which is really akin to a private plaintiff, occupying an office. It's never seemed like an office to me. It seemed like a kind of nebulous role, but maybe not an office.
Lastly, Judge Mazzell rejected arguments that key Tam provisions have historically been permitted, dating to the early Congresses. She echoed her old boss, Justice Thomas, here, that historical patterns standing alone cannot justify contemporary violations of constitutional guarantees. And she emphasized that key Tam suits were uncommon until the 1986 amendments that increased for later incentives. They provided for those shares 15-30% of the settlement and judgment recovery, and also for attorney's fees recovery. Zaporov has not proven a continuous, unbroken practice throughout our nation's history that might otherwise inform an ambiguous constitutional text.
So, Judge Mazzell dismissed Zaffarov's suit. She concluded that the FCA's key Tam provisions directly defy the Appointments Clause by permitting unaccountable, unsworn private actors to exercise core executive power with substantial consequences to members of the public.
And this is an important epilogue to this whole presentation. Defendants also argued that additional cons… they raised additional constitutional arguments that the FCA's key Tam provisions violated both the Take Care Clause and the Vesting Clause of Article 2. But Judge Mazzell did not reach these arguments, in dismissing solely on the basis of appointments… the basis of the Appointments Clause. And again, not to spoil the ending, but now we have to… we're back at the District Court having to consider, the constitutionality of the FCA key Tam provisions in light of the Take Care Clause and the Vesting Clause.
For background, the Take Care Clause provides that the President shall take care that laws be faithfully executed. The Vesting Clause provides that the executive power shall be vested in a president of the United States of America. And these arguments, again, relate to the unitary executive theory regarding the extent to which the President must exercise complete control over executive branch actions. But again, Judge Mazzell ruled only that the FCA key Tam provisions violated the Appointments Clause, and she didn't reach these arguments related to the other two clauses.
So, Zafrov caused shockwaves, and threatening to upend the FCA's QTam regime that we've discussed is responsible for thousands of cases and billions of dollars in judgments and recoveries annually to relators and to the federal government. I mean, if you see those pages of search engine results discussing Zafrov. it really traces to the district court decision and the implications that people saw with that ruling and what it could mean for cases nationally.
Here in the Ninth Circuit, I would say that the effects were relatively minimal. The Ninth Circuit held in 1983 that key Tam provisions did not violate Article 2, in a case U.S. X-Rail Kelly v. Boeing. Ninth Circuit district courts uniformly followed this precedent from Kelly, and none adopted Judge Mazzell's reasoning or ruling. We cite cases here from the federal district courts in Alaska, Arizona, California, and Hawaii that followed the Circuit precedent. And in some cases, they were even dismissive of Judge Mazzell's ruling from the NEMA case in Arizona. Ultimately, this Court finds no reason to disregard binding Ninth Circuit authority and the nationwide circuit trend on account of a single outlier trial court decision that whistles past precedent binding upon this court. So, not very, not a very generous view of Judge Mazzell's ruling. In the Kenley Emergency Medicine case, this Court is bound by Circuit precedent, not a district court opinion, or even a dissent or a concurrence by a Supreme Court justice. So, key Tam actions remain viable in the Ninth Circuit, and they likely will continue to remain viable unless and until the Supreme Court itself rules to the contrary.
You know, on the other hand, though, other circuits were more supportive of Justice Thomas's and Judge Mazzell's arguments. In the Fifth Circuit, two judges in two separate cases urged further consideration of the constitutional concerns with the key Tam provisions. Judge James Ho, key Tam relators presume to represent the United States government in federal court, and to defend the interests of the United States Treasury against fraud, but like federal civil servants, they are neither appointed by nor accountable to the President. And echoing Justice Kavanaugh's concurrence here in an appropriate case, we should revisit whether there are serious constitutional problems with the QTam provisions of the False Claims Act. And Judge Kyle Duncan, it seems inescapable that the FCA's QTam device violates the Appointments Clause, adding that the FCA outsources prosecutorial power to a private person. Judge Ho was a former clerk of Justice Thomas's as well, and until the midterm elections, I think both of these judges were probably considered shortlist potential Supreme Court appointees for, President Trump in the last two years of his term.
And that would have further swayed the possibility of the FCA key Tam provisions being declared unconstitutional, I would say, if a case came before the court.
The Zafrov dismissal was appealed to the Eleventh Circuit, and as I mentioned, it took nearly 2 years for the court to rule. It was a very long wait, with significant implications for the future of FCA cases, and if you ever… curious, you know, about how significant Zafrov was. There were 62 attorneys, listed as counsel of record between the parties and all the amici who submitted briefs to the Eleventh Circuit, and just a staggering number of attorneys who were involved in this case.
On September 1st, the Eleventh Circuit reversed, Judge Mazzell's ruling. It was a unanimous three-judge opinion, authored by Judge Elizabeth Branch, who was a Trump appointee. And for as closely watched as the Eleventh Circuit decision was, you know, the court actually issued what I would describe as a pretty brief and narrow opinion. The Eleventh Circuit held that relators do not occupy a continuing position, which, as we discussed, was just one half of the test for what constituted an appointee, an officer subject to the Appointments Clause. Zafrov and the government additionally argued in support of reversal that relators are private parties pursuing private interests, and they therefore do not exercise executive power, and they don't exercise significant authority. The court did not consider these arguments, as well as arguments about key Tam actions being historically permitted. Again, it was a very narrow ruling just on the, the issue. factor of whether officers occupy… whether relators occupy a continuing position such that they should be considered officers.
In its ruling, the Eleventh Circuit considered the tenure, the duration, the emulment, and the duties of a relator. An emulment, a fancy word that I needed to look up, is the salary, fee, or profit that an individual, and in this case a relator, receives. essentially the question of whether a relator or an officer receives a government salary. The analysis of tenure and duration was overlapping, and the court noted that while some relators, like Zafrov, litigate cases for years, others may have cases dismissed within the 60-day seal period itself. And here were some of the court's conclusions regarding tenure and duration.
A relator's tenure is occasional and temporary because it lasts the length of one case, a relator may bring multiple cases in a year or none, and relators are not required to keep a place of business. Accordingly, a relator's intermittent, non-permanent tenure tends to show that he does not hold a continuing position. And the Supreme Court is not focused on the overall length of a person's time fulfilling his duties when evaluating the duration of the position.
Regarding whether relators receive a continuing enrollment, the Eleventh Circuit emphasized that relators only receive payment as a one-time award, contingent on the success of their case. They receive compensation through a portion of the judgment. They work on an intermittent basis whenever they have a claim to pursue, and the litigation is active. And they face no penalty for refusal to perform, except for the loss of the opportunity to receive a contingent fee for succeeding on a given case, if successful.
The court concluded that relators' duties are personal and they can't be assumed by others. And the court held that while the length of any given FCA case is uncertain and variable, relators have temporary tenure and duration No continuing enrollment and personal duties, so they do not occupy a continuing position. So, the Eleventh Circuit disagreed with Judge Mazzell's conclusion about relators occupying a continuing central office.
Back to the arguments analogizing relators to bank receivers and independent counsels. The Eleventh Circuit distinguished independent counsels from relators by noting that if an independent counsel resigned or was removed, or replacement picked up the work right where his predecessor left off, even if it was in the middle of a case or an investigation. You know, by contrast, if a relator abandoned a claim, or potentially even died, the FCA does not provide for their replacement. Independent counsels are also paid through a Department of Justice appropriation, while relators receive a share of the judgment or the settlement they help obtain.
And the Eleventh Circuit reversed, and it remanded to the District Court to evaluate the Take Care Investing Clause arguments. So, not back to the beginning, but back for another analysis of the constitutionality of the FCA.
So, the implications of the Eleventh Circuit Ruling. There's continued uncertainty regarding constitutionality of key Tam actions under the FCA, though I would say it's less settled than in the two years that folks were waiting for the Eleventh Circuit to rule in Zafirov. The defendants potentially could have sought cert on the Appointments Clause question at the Supreme Court, but they've returned to the District Court for now. I assume that defendants will find a sympathetic audience for their taking care clause, investing clause arguments with Judge Mazzell. on remand. She has certainly expressed her sort of disdain for the FCA's key Tam provisions and the power that they give relators. And there's a November 23rd status conference coming up, where the parties have to address how these arguments will be analyzed. They must be prepared to address the Eleventh Circuit's opinion, separating the Take Care Clause from the vesting Clause and what legal test applies to each, or whether the two clauses should be analyzed together as the parties previously recap.
The government, which you recall, didn't initially intervene, but is now fully, involved, has emphasized that Congress routinely provides for private suits to enforce federal statutes, for public benefit. The government and the relator have argued that the Take Care Investing clauses are complementary and overlapping. The Take Care Clause establishes that the execution of the laws is a central component of executive function of the United States, and the vesting clause places that power in the president's hand. Their position is that the constitutionality of the FCA's key Tam provisions with respect to the two clauses should be analyzed together. the Eleventh Circuit's opinion does not suggest that the key Tam provisions could violate one clause without violating the other, or could be consistent with one clause without being consistent with the other. Essentially, they're saying there's no space between, for a separate analysis of the implications under the Take Care and the Vesting Clause. If the key Tam provisions are constitutional under one, they're constitutional under both. If they're unconstitutional under one, they're unconstitutional under both.
The government noted the example of private lawsuits that are used to enforce anti-discrimination and antitrust laws, related to exercising executive power by private relators for public benefit. The government also emphasized the supposed control it exercises over relator suits. A key Tam action cannot proceed, it can't even be unsealed until after the government has had an opportunity to determine whether to intervene and proceed with the action. Intervene and move to dismiss it, or allow the relator to conduct the action subject to ongoing government oversight. As I mentioned earlier, you know, the degree of that oversight is debatable. The government can intervene to dismiss a relator suit at any time, but the relator may also have the ability to litigate for years without the government's involvement or with minimal involvement by the government. The government, though, claims it retains absolute control over the action from the moment it is unsealed.
At the same time, you know, the government conceded in a brief filed this month that the KTam device is unusual. Relators do not need to show a personal injury themselves to have standing, but rather sue on a partial assignment of the government's right to recovery. And unlike a typical case where a plaintiff recovers any judgment solely for themselves, the government actually receives the majority of any judgment or settlement.
The government said this in a brief just this month. If Congress's use of the QTam mechanism were a new development, these features of QTam actions under the False Claims Act would give rise to substantial questions about whether such actions are consistent with the vesting and take care clauses. But the government and the relator returned to the fact that key Tam suits have a long history of being permitted to overcome, sort of, the unusualness of the scheme. A history of key Tam provisions dating to the founding support that they are understood, as the government put it, as established features of American law.
The Relators cited a record of 9 key Tam suits that were authorized by the 1st Congress alone, and 35 key Tam suits that were enacted by the first 9 Congresses. There is a… there is a history of George Washington consulting with Alexander Hamilton. on the ability to pardon a customs inspector who had been sued under a key Tam provision. Hamilton's advice was that Washington could return the portion of the fine that was paid to the U.S. government, but not the portion the defendant paid to the private informer under the key Tam statute. And, you know, if you think about it, it really doesn't get more originalist than that. From the government's brief, it would be exceedingly surprising if Chief Justice Marshall, Chief Justice Jay, and Secretary Hamilton simply overlooked the constitutional infirmities of these suits. And the relator, argued, had there been a valid constitutional argument or objection to these laws under Article 2, these learned framers surely would have raised it in jealous defense of their clients. The fact that they didn't is strong evidence that no such defense, was available.
we'll see, you know, how that is received by Judge Mazzell, and probably ultimately the Eleventh Circuit on the historical arguments. I think Judge Mazzell, in particular, noted that, really, the FCA key Tam provisions didn't start being used in the numbers that you see today until after the 1986 amendments, so there is less of a historical precedent of at least, you know, the key Tam suits under the FCA that would not, sort of, that can overcome this history that's cited by the government and the relator in this case.
We'll wait to see how Judge Mazel rules on these additional Article 2 arguments, but I expect defendants will find a sympathetic audience with her. The government has already argued that Judge Mazel should not declare the key Tam provisions unconstitutional full stop, but she should sever any provisions that limit the government's ability to control key Tam litigation, such as, you know, the requirement of good cause for the government to intervene after declining to do so, or the relator's right to participate in the litigation after the government's intervention. The government argues that both of those provisions should be severed from the statute to preserve constitutionality.
If the ultimate goal is to challenge the FCA's constitutionality at the Supreme Court, you know, defendants are seemingly still years away from doing so, with the District Court and the Eleventh Circuit both needing to rule again. In the background, though, there's still three justices who seem inclined to grant review at some time in the future, based on their opinions. in Polanski, and they may have the opportunity, not necessarily through these Eleventh Circuit cases, they may find a Fifth Circuit case, for example, that they can grant cert on. It seems like defendants in Zafrov at least, have decided it's best to package all of the constitutional questions in one appeal to the Supreme Court.
So, until we get a definitive ruling from the Supreme Court, we can expect to see billions of dollars in FCA recoveries and hundreds of cases filed annually, I don't see that pattern, pattern breaking at any point. If the key Tam provisions are ultimately held unconstitutional, the government still could bring FCA suits itself, FCA claims itself. In cases filed by relators, the government may have to decide whether to intervene at the very outset, or potentially in all cases, to address the concern about relators independently litigating on behalf of the government. As I mentioned, it's really the cases where the government doesn't intervene and the relator is left to litigate for years on its own and on behalf of the government that have really raised the most concern. The government will likely need to exercise some degree of control over a relator action when it doesn't intervene to satisfy constitutional concerns.
And, you know, relatedly, a new program arose just last month related to whistleblowers and financial payouts. It may have gotten lost in the lead-up to the midterms, but President Trump announced on October 20th the creation of this Fraud Whistleblower incentive Program. I mentioned it at the very start of the presentation. It's known by this acronym of WIP.
In contrast to the FCA, according to the government, the intention of WIP is to reward whistleblowers at a much earlier stage of prosecution. And does not require the matter to result in large fines or forfeitures. So, attempting to provide whistleblowers with a source of funds earlier than, you know, these 4- or 5-year FCA cases, with such a long duration. These early-stage rewards aim to give whistleblowers more certainty about the amount and timing of a potential reward payment, while still leaving whistleblowers eligible for potentially larger rewards should their tips ultimately lead to larger financial penalties or forfeiture. So you see potential of this WIP program and the FCA working side-by-side with relators.
potentially receiving a WIP payment at the beginning, if there is criminal charges that are brought related to their complaint or their tips, and then a potential FCA payout later. WIP will pay whistleblowers an award of $10,000 to $30,000 for information leading to criminal charges for certain frauds. And these are characterized as fast-track payments. And President Trump actually characterized the program differently, in the White House announcement. He claimed it would provide a 1% commission. Based on the value of the fraud, which would be, obviously, dramatically more than the $10,000 To $30,000 payments that the WIP program ostensibly would provide. I think, it seems like the… the figures from the DOJ website of $10,000 to $30,000 WIP payments is what the government is actually going to move forward with, and not this 1% commission that President Trump mentioned. Possibly erroneously.
So, based on this announcement, it seems like a relator could be eligible for both a WIP payment and a later FCA payment, as long as the TIP or the KTam complaint resulted in criminal charges. It really remains to be seen, you know, how many payments the government will make under this WIP program, if it is anything that has staying power, if it's something that's attractive to relators.
So far, there's been exactly one payment, $10,000 to Nick Shirley, related to his investigations of alleged childcare fraud in Minnesota. And there's some question about whether this WIP program is even necessary, given, you know, the significant incentives for relators, to bring FCA claims and recover what we discussed, the 15% to 30% value of a settlement, or, a judgment. I don't think many relators are going to choose a $10,000 WIP payment when there's the possibility of recovering 15-30% of a settlement or judgment in an FCA case.
But, you know, the Trump administration has made a huge fraud, a huge enforcement priority. There's seemingly a fraud announcement every single month coming from the administration, and the WIP program is ostensibly intended to address Four areas of fraud. Hospice fraud, home health fraud, daycare fraud, and special services fraud, which is for programs like autism care. We've seen that the government bring a number of, sort of, strike force enforcement actions and prosecutions related to these four areas in California, and in some other blue states.
I'd also add the WIP program is a 3-year program, so we'll see where it is after 3 years, but the initial timeframe for the program is 3 years.
I definitely had questions about under what authority the program was being instituted. You know, is it an extension of the FCA? What is it? There was not really a lot of explanation as part of the initial announcement. There was a lot of questions from reporters about why are you even launching this program if you have a False Claims Act? So I looked it up in the department's announcement, and it's authorized through the Attorney General's power to pay Rewards of up to $3 million in criminal cases. As part of that, there's no reward of $250,000 that can be offered without the President or the Attorney General's personal approval. And there's some very interesting, considerations if this WIP program is really utilized.
You know, for one, it requires that tips lead to criminal charges, but what happens if the criminal charges don't actually result in convictions? You know, we've seen the Trump administration pursue criminal charges in cases like the reflecting pool modernization, that were quickly dismissed.
Also, the Department of Justice repeatedly disclaims that it has the authority to approve awards in its sole discretion, and the reward determination is neither appealable nor subject to judicial review. You know, I don't know how many whistleblowers are likely to litigate a WIP payment that they didn't receive that only totals $30,000. I mean, the cost of litigating that is potentially significant, but it's interesting that the government expressly disclaims any kind of judicial review over these payments. The tip must be based on non-public information not previously known to the department. And the tipster can't have a management role over personnel or the offices that were involved in the misconduct. So it remains to be seen how attractive this program will be, how it'll complement the FCA, but a lot of FCA echoes in terms of payments to whistleblowers, and in this case, trying to make payments to whistleblowers early.
So, I would say stay tuned, in 2027 to see what the District Court does with the Zafroff case on remand. We could essentially go through the uncertainty again with a ruling that the FCA key Tam provisions violate, the Take Care Clause or the Vesting Clause. hopefully we don't have to wait 2 years for the Eleventh Circuit to weigh in again on, whatever Judge Mazzell rules. If… also see if there will be renewed questioning by other district courts nationally, or if Judge Mazzell's ruling, assuming it's favorable to the defendants and unfavorable to the constitutionality of key Tam provisions, will be treated as an outlier again.
And if the government ultimately decides to intervene sooner or exercise greater control over these later cases to potentially avoid, some of these questions in non-intervention cases and avoid, you know, the possibility that you may see an adverse ruling at the Supreme Court that could invalidate some cases, you know, the government may choose To exercise more intervention power to sort of hedge the risk of that.
And we'll also see whether the Trump administration attempts to make use of this WIP program that it rolled out, or whether it moves on to other things. So, I'm happy to answer any questions, that folks have. There's also a client alert that I authored, along with another DWT partner, white-collar partner, Alex Porter, on our website regarding the Zafrov Ruling.
I appreciate everyone joining, and I hope you have a great rest of your week, and a good Thanksgiving, and good holidays.